1939 - 70th Anniversary

Seventy years ago - even before I was born - Hollywood capped its Golden Age with a year of releases that still sparkle, like pearls in a priceless necklace: Gone With The Wind, The Wizard Of Oz, Ninotchka, Gunga Din, Stagecoach, Dark Victory, Mr. Smith Goes To Washington, Wuthering Heights, My Little Chickadee, Destry Rides Again, Only Angels Have Wings, Babes In Arms, The Man In The Iron Mask, At The Circus, The Story Of Irene And Vernon Castle.

The nation was slowly emerging from The Great Depression and was fearful of the imminent world war that had been looming for years and began that September. Americans were isolationists, thirsty for home grown diversions. Forty million Americans (one in three) went to see at least one movie every week. They would first see a newsreel and then some cartoons, a short, and a double feature - a first run "A" film accompanied by a "B" picture.

The major studios, like automobile manufacturers, spewed product from their factories in assembly line fashion - at MGM, nearly one new release each week. It was the age of dictators and each studio, major or independent, had its signature personality, formed by the whims and taste of its production head, its mogul: Mayer, Goldwyn, Warner, Cohen, Selznick and the others. Each had its stable of contract stars and supporting players, writers, producers, directors, crafts people who had perfected the magic of motion picture making.

Because of the misery in Europe, a flood of talented creative juices infused Hollywood. Writers, directors, composers, actors, found haven and gave fresh perspective to dramas, comedies, musicals, adding wit, style, sophistication to the product.

To be sure, the films we remember and still watch seventy years later were the cream of a crop that included plenty of trash that was quickly forgotten. These were factory products, mass produced, consumed, and disposed - never intended for the ages. But it is clear that the year was remarkable for its output and deserves its place as the best single year in Hollywood’s history.

Although post war fashion dictated that the greatest movies were product of "auteurs", these were fabricated by the collaborative efforts of company employees and contractees. However, the stamp of iconoclastic forceful producers such as Goldwyn, LeRoy, and Selznick, and of visionary directors like Hawks, Ford, Stevens, Fleming, Berkeley, and Wyler marked the output.

Ninotchka
MGM. Director: Ernst Lubitsch. Adapted Screenplay: Charles Brackett & Billy Wilder with Walter Reisch. Greta Garbo, Melvyn Douglas, Sig Ruman, Felix Bressart.
Lubitsch was one of the most influential European filmmakers, who specialized in sophisticated light romantic comedies. The "Lubitsch Touch" was exemplified in The Merry Widow, Design For Living, The Shop Around The Corner, To Be Or Not To Be, Cluny Brown, and in Ninotchka, where he teased a delightful comedic performance from Garbo.
The script has fun with Soviet Russia’s pompous drab seriousness compared with the radiant frivolity of Paris of the 1930's, an attitude that was popular with the supposedly left leaning writers of the era. Garbo is a dour commissar sent to check up on three wandering envoys who had been assigned the task of acquiring jewelry now in possession of a White Russian aristocrat. Douglas is (only slightly miscast as) a Parisian playboy, who introduces Ninotchka to the joys of decadence. Once he gets Garbo to laugh, she lights up the screen. More than her melodramas, it is the role in which modern audiences can appreciate her attraction.

The formula has become a cliche of romantic comedy. Cole Porter wrote the music for the hit show and film that adapted it, Silk Stockings (Fred Astaire and Cyd Charisse).

Gone With The Wind:
MGM / Selznick. The highest grossing film of the year, it was also the most expensive to produce. The course of its travel from best selling novel of 1936 to screen has been chronicled more than any other movie of any time - in documentaries and innumerable books. This week’s New Yorker includes David Denby’s appreciation of Victor Fleming, an article which mentions two new books, one by Molly Haskell who notes the movie’s cultural impact.

My own view is that once the generation which venerates this film passes away, it will be rated much lower on any list of great American films. Once thought the epitome of the Hollywood epic, it has not stood the test of societal changes in attitude toward African Americans, women’s roles, the presumed nobility of the ante-bellum and post-Civil War South. As bad history and negative cultural stereotyping, it is a bad influence. Some of the acting and writing is hopelessly dated, and some performances are embarrassing to watch.
Still, it grandly symbolizes a universal romantic dilemma for women: between love of a sensitive, soulful, poetic man (Ashley Wilkes / Leslie Howard) and the attraction to rough, sexy males (Rhett Butler /Clark Gable); whether to prize kindness and goodness (Melanie / Olivia DeHaviland) or accept her impulse for risk-taking independence and selfish grasping of power (Scarlett / Vivien Leigh). As such it was a primer for adolescent females of the era, and probably still speaks to girls of a certain age, like Wuthering Heights.
Scarlett is a form of the "anti-heroine" of the 1930's, which was personified elsewhere by Bette Davis, Joan Crawford and Barbara Stanwyck. She schemes, deceives, rails, is passionate and sexy, determined and strong. Leigh was unique because of her fresh sexuality and crystal beauty.
A subtext of the success of the novel and the film is its perspective of war as seen from the woman’s point of view: as an insane and selfish bellowing of bulls bent on the destruction of a "pretty society," an attitude which struck a loud chord in the pacifist America of the 1930's.

This is what Ebert now observes:
"How does Gone with the Wind play after fifty years? It is still a great film, above all because it tells a great story. Scarlett O'Hara, willful, spoiled, scarred by poverty, remains an unforgettable screen heroine, and I was struck again this time by how strong Vivien Leigh's performance is—by how stubbornly she maintains her petulance in the face of common sense, and by how even her heroism is undermined by her character flaws.
"The ending of the film still plays like a psychological test for the audience. What do you think we should really conclude? The next-to-last speech in the movie, Rhett Butler's ‘Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn,’ is one many audience members have been waiting for; Scarlett gets her comeuppance at last. Then comes her speech about Tara, about how, after all, tomorrow is another day. Some members of the audience will read this as an affirmation of strength, others as a renewed self-delusion. (The most cynical will observe that Scarlett, like many another divorcee disappointed in love, has turned to real estate as a career.)"

It has also been the subject of TV sequels and parodies, the best a classic skit by Carole Burnett who fashioned a dress from her velvet drapes, but kept the curtain rods as shoulder pads.

The Wizard of Oz :
MGM. Producer: Mervyn LeRoy. Director: Victor Fleming (and King Vidor). Cinematographer: Harold Rosson (other credits: Treasure Island, Captains Courageous, Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo, The Asphalt Jungle, The Red Badge of Courage). Music: Harold Arlen & E. Y. Harburg. Art Direction: Cedric Gibbons. Makeup: Jack Dawn. Adapted Screenplay: Noel Langley and Florence Ryerson. Judy Garland, Frank Morgan, Billie Burke, Margaret Hamilton, Ray Bolger, Burt Lahr, Jack Haley.
One of the best examples of the remarkable range of creative talents which the Hollywood studio system at the height of its power could harness. MGM desperately tried to get Shirley Temple, settled for their own contract juvenile, the chubby seventeen year old Judy Garland. Mervin LeRoy was the producer, and Victor Fleming was assigned to direct — in the same year he took over the direction of Gone With The Wind!
A spectacular collaboration of Harold Arlen’s tuneful songs with memorable and clever adult rhymes, the nubile Judy Garland at the pinnacle of her precocious power, and a wonderful cast of scene-stealers including The Witch of all witches (Margaret Hamilton), imaginative costumes, sets, spectacular use of color, plenty of wit for the grown-ups — it all adds up to the most watchable children’s fantasy musical ever made.
Beneath it all, as I see it, lies a dark metaphor of the terrors of a girl growing up, leaving home, becoming a woman in a scary, male, adult world. She has flawed male role models to choose from: ranging from the strong but heartless, dumb but sweet, cowardly but cute, and the older man who claims wiz-dom.
It owes its theme to Alice in Wonderland, but from then on, the originality and universality sparkles. It is fun to see it as an in-parable of MGM: Judy is the exploited child / woman trying to escape from the fantasy world controlled by the wizard, Louis B. Mayer, the dream manipulator, and to go home for rest and sleep while Mayer keeps her working for him, awake with psychedelic drugs.
One minor downside of the films’ values which has always disturbed me: after her great adventure, Dorothy seems to have learned a lesson: "There’s no place like home." Apart from being sappy, that always struck me as somewhat reactionary; we should not seek "our heart’s desire" by escaping drab tedium and expanding our horizons. Maybe this is a secret political theme of isolationism, considering the film’s timing, an escape from the looming tornado of world war.

Mr. Smith Goes to Washington:
Columbia. Director: Frank Capra. Screenplay: Sidney Buchman (credits: Theodora Goes Wild, Lost Horizon, Holiday.) James Stewart, Jean Arthur, Claude Rains, Edward Arnold, Eugene Pallette,Thomas Mitchell, Harry Carey, H. B. Warner, Ruth Donnelly,
The unlikely possibility that naive idealism can overcome organized corruption is appealingly argued by Stewart and Capra. Suspension of disbelief is a must. As a genre, political films are rarely "great" because, if good they are timely and therefore become dated quickly. One of my favorites, State of the Union is later (1948) Capra. Seeing it today, it bears the Capra stamp of uplifting cynicism about manipulative politicians along with the sentimental hokum of American symbols of our goodness that I am a sucker for. Capra making a political film is like the remark about Sinatra singing a love ballad: "The jerk really believes all that bull!" And both make you believe, too.

A word about Jean Arthur, who was one of the treasures of the screwball comedy era (You Can’t Take It With You, Mr. Deeds Goes to Town, The More The Merrier, and The Talk of the Town and Wilder’s later Foreign Affair). She is my fantasy of a perfect woman: bright, funny, ironic, tough but sentimental, painfully attractive to look at and listen to.
In You Can’t Take It With You, she and James Stewart have three scenes together that epitomize the essence of 1930's romantic comedy as filtered through the sentimental imagination of Frank Capra. Arthur plays Stewart’s secretary. She comes from a ditzy family which meets The Great Depression by accentuating their eccentricities and having a blast. His father is wealthy banker, Edward Arnold, who was Capra’s favorite heavy, a pompous powerful capitalist.
The first scene between the love birds is in the office; Jimmy holds Jean’s hands and coos to her so ardently that she can’t answer the phone. She has to nuzzle it with her nose to the desk and does half the scene with her hair facing the camera. The result is as sexy as it could be. The second scene has the two lovers sitting on a park bench, smooching, and Jimmy talking about his goofy dreams. Arthur mostly reacts, just looking at him as he speaks, and her face is to die for. The third scene is in a ritzy restaurant. Jimmy says he feels a scream rising from his toes, and fears he can’t hold it back. Jean scolds him, and becomes progressively alarmed as Jimmy’s face becomes more and more likely to scream. Suddenly, she screams. It is a hilarious scene, made of just a silly moment of anarchy, of the extreme talents of two wonderful entertainers, pretending to be and becoming a perfect couple.
In Mr. Smith, Jean Arthur evinces the same magical ability to show intelligence, sex appeal, screwball wit, and sentimentality, whether in successive scenes or simultaneous moments. If you want to find a primer on comedic romantic acting, Jean Arthur is the absolute master. (Her closest contemporary mimic is Meg Ryan – place them side by side and see who you prefer. No contest.)

Snow White:
Over all, I prefer Who Framed Roger Rabbit; but as the first of its genre, a full-length animated feature, it was certainly a landmark. "Whistle While You Work," "Some Day My Prince Will Come," Dopey, Prince Charming, the Wicked Witch, the velvety Disney animation touch, whistling and singing animal pals, the fairy tale for pre-adolescent girls. Disney copied the formula so often that it makes the first effort look trite when viewed again.

Stagecoach:
Director: John Ford. Screenplay: Dudley Nichols (other credits: The Informer, Bringing Up Baby) John Wayne, Thomas Mitchell, Claire Trevor, John Carradine, George Bancroft, Andy Devine, Donald Meek, Tim Holt (see below).
John Ford’s sweeping western vistas, and lean power of a young John Wayne. The film accumulates practically every Western cliché character and situation and somehow manages to be convincing and enjoyable throughout. Historically important, it made the western into an A movie, moving the genre and Wayne along with it, away from Saturday matinee hell. It was also the precursor of the "adult western" in which all the stock characters of westerns: dance hall girls, dudes, drunks, are depicted as more real people: prostitutes, homosexuals, tragic flotsam. It also contains the elements for the pattern of Ford’s myth making cinema: the creation of heroes (lone gunslingers, settlers, the cavalry) and villains (Indians, city slickers, bankers, bureaucrats, cowards).
How’s this for trivia: this is the second film on this list for one of the worst actors ever: the cavalry officer is Tim Holt, (one of the three leads in The Treasure of Sierra Madre). Holt also had the central role in Orson Welles’ flawed near masterpiece, The Magnificent Ambersons.

Wuthering Heights:
Goldwyn. Director: William Wyler. Screenplay adapted by Charles McArthur with Ben Hecht (whose screen credits define the Golden Age: Scarface, Viva Villa, Design For Living, Twentieth Century) Laurence Olivier, Merle Oberon, David Niven, Donald Crisp, Leo G. Carroll, Geraldine Fitzgerald, Cecil Kelloway.
Bijou was a lonely young girl who spent a lot of time in the local library reading novels which were on the shelf in alphabetical order by author; so she read all of Austin and the Brontes. When she grew up, we traveled in Europe. She found this novel — which she had loved reading as a pre-adolescent — in a bed and breakfast bin, and re-read it with great anticipation — and disappointment. As a grown woman, she was struck by her realization that the story actually reflects the transparent and immature repressed sexual fantasies of the Emily Bronte, who had been daughter of a stern minister living in pre-Victorian English isolation. The film, wildly romantic to its viewers in 1939, now seems hopelessly silly and over-the-top ... at least, until one considers Titanic.

Interestingly, the modern erotic story line (as in Unfaithful) twists this plot almost beyond recognition. In the modern women’s fantasy, she is in a stable, boring, sexless relationship and craves the dark, unruly, sexy Heathcliff type, has a wild affair with him, then it ends or doesn’t. Here, Cathy starts with Heathcliff, but drops him for the stuffed shirt, but he is the obsessed character who is fatally attracted to her. He pursues her to the point of destroying her life and his, until, on her death bed she admits her passionate love, her eternal tie to him.
Still, the production is first rate movie making. William Wyler directed, with Gregg Toland behind the camera, a script by Hecht and MacArthur, Alfred Newman’s music. They create a rich atmosphere of turbulent passions. Laurence Olivier shows his power in his dark chiseled looks and rich powerful voice, and Merle Oberon, never a great actress in a generation of great screen actresses is believable in the role of The Woman of 1939: vain, fragile, determined, mercurial, just like Vivian Leigh in GWTW and Bette Davis in Jezebel.
Like another tale of tragic juvenile love, Romeo And Juliet, the story continues to speak across generations of romantic girls. In the 90's it was filmed on the moors with more authentic atmosphere and sense of the era with Ralph Fiennes, Juliet Binoche and Colin Firth.
Then, as proof of its primary audience, MTV has recently updated the story to contemporary US teenville. Heathcliff became "Heath", a mysterious and sexy rock music composer and performer. "Cate" (again) marries the wealthy Edward, whose sister, Isabel, is tragically enamored of Heath. There is a lot of moaning, deep and wet kisses, commercials, and bad music. To cash in on the tweener’s romantic ideal of modern tragedy, Cate dies in childbirth this time (as in the novel), and later, Heath is shown riding his chopper with his and Cate’s child on the back, to the strains of some pop melody, while Cate’s spirit approves.

Dark Victory:
Warners. Exec. Producer: Hal. B. Wallis. Director: Edmund Goulding. Screenplay: Casey Robinson (also credited with Captain Blood, Tovarish, King’s Row, Pride Of The Yankees, Now, Voyager.) Bette Davis, George Brent, Geraldine Fitzgerald, Ronald Reagan, Humphrey Bogart. Score: Max Steiner (A famous story goes that Bette Davis asked the director if Steiner was going to underscore her final scene, in which she climbs a flight of stairs as blindness closes in, signaling her impending tragic death. When he hesitated, she ordered: "Either Max goes up those stairs, or I do. But I’ll be damned if I go up there with him.")
Bette Davis was a remarkable star. She was a unique sort of woman in films. Her personality was so powerful that she plowed through all her many unattractive defects to grab you despite your better judgment. She was at her best in soapy melodramas that she elevated to something that was almost human, through sheer determination and personality.
Dark Victory is a tearjerker of the most shameful sort, but is a good example of her power. Davis plays a spoiled heiress who leads a shallow life. Suddenly she develops headaches, double vision, and is cajoled into meeting the very serious George Brent, a brain surgeon. He operates on Bette’s brain, and fails to tell her that she is going to die in less than a year. Bette falls in love with George. Then she discovers the deception, rails at the world and George, finally gives in and marries him. They are happy for the few months they have together in wintry Vermont living a simple life and finding peace of mind. Then Bette feels the onset of the final stages of her "very rare" but convenient movie illness, in which there are no symptoms until a few hours before she is to die, when the world will grow dark. Bette faces the end courageously and alone (except for Steiner’s score), grateful for the love she has had.
The miracle is how compelling Davis makes this film. Though certainly not a beauty in the mold of Garbo, Hepburn, or many others, Davis manages to make herself riveting to look at. Her eyes, those Bette Davis Eyes, are her major attribute in film acting. They express everything. Her voice is sometimes metallic and overpowering, her mannerisms harsh and over-emoting. She moves about, wrings her hands, waves her cigarettes and punctuates her dialogue with vitriolic flair. But she is like a child who is so persistently aggressive that she demands your attention, forces you to take the trip with her, and finally to feel for her. She showed the same kind of power in most of her Bette Davis films.

Only Angels Have Wings:
Columbia. Howard Hawks directed a paean to flyers. Screenplay by Jules Furthman (also credited with The Big Sleep, To Have and Have Not, Bombshell, Mutiny On The Bounty). Starring Cary Grant, Jean Arthur, newcomer Rita Hayworth, and the ubiquitous Thomas Mitchell (who was in every other movie released that year). Score: Dimitri Tiomkin.
Hawks idealizes the between-the-wars masculine ideal, men of action who grieve with gallows humor, hard drinking, and yield only to women who can be pals as well as tolerant lovers.

Gunga Din:
R.K.O. Director: George Stevens. Screenplay: typical of the studio system, many writers worked without screen credit, including: William Faulkner, Ben Hecht, Dudley Nichols, Anthony Veiler. The story is credited to Hecht & MacArthur, who fashioned it from the Kipling poem. Joel Sayre & Fred Guiol got the screen credit. Starring Cary Grant, Victor McLaglen, Douglas Fairbanks, Jr., Sam Jaffe, Eduardo Ciannelli, Joan Fontaine, Montagu Love, Robert Coote. Score: Alfred Newman. (One of the uncredited editors was John Sturges - later director of such as Bad Day At Black Rock, The Old Man And The Sea, The Magnificent Seven, The Great Escape). Cinematographer: Joseph August (Portrait Of Jennie).
A terrific adventure film, one of the templates that George Lucas and Steven Spielberg cite as influential to Star Wars and Indiana Jones. A buddy movie, a service comedy, a swashbuckler. Cary Grant, whose sophisticated screwball comedy chops had been established, now hit as an action star with dash and wit, Cockney charm, mixing it up with the gruff MacLaglen and debonair Fairbanks.
Viewed by today’s sensibilities, the clinker of English snobbery toward India, highlighted by darkened skinned Jaffe (a veteran of Yiddish theatre) and Italian actor Ciannelli, must be swallowed to enjoy the fun.

George Stevens, of course, is one of the great film makers of all time. Beginning in silents as cameraman, writer, then as director and producer, master of films in all genres: Alice Adams, Annie Oakley, Swing Time, Woman Of The Year, The More The Merrier, A Place In The Sun, Shane, Giant, The Diary Of Anne Frank.

Destry Rides Again:
Universal. Producer: Joe Pasternak (Anchors Aweigh, Director: George Marshall. Marlene Dietrich, James Stewart, Mischa Auer, Charles Wininger, Brian Donlevy, Una Merkel.
The anti-violent Western in which Stewart plays a pacifist as sheriff. Jimmy’s stammering boyishness mixes with Dietrich’s inflammatory sultriness producing very funny and sexy chemistry, especially in a scene in which she has a knock down cat fight with Una Merkel, which Jimmy tries to mediate.

At The Circus:
MGM. The Marx Brothers, Margaret Dumont, Eve Arden. Screenplay credited to Irving Brecher (other credits: Meet Me In St. Louis, The Life Of Riley), though as in all Marx films, it is hard to know how much the boys improvised.
The film is lesser Marx, certainly not on a par with the earlier A Night At The Opera for MGM, but there are the usual moments of insanity and pun-ishment of the language for which they are best remembered.

Babes In Arms:
MGM. Producer: Arthur Freed. Director: Busby Berkeley. Screenplay: Jack McGowan (Broadway Melody of 1940, Lady Be Good). Songs by Rodgers & Hart, Nacio Herb Brown. Mickey Rooney, Judy Garland.
The first and most original and exhuberant of the Berkeley / Rooney / Garland "lets put on a show" movies. Berkeley exploits their talents to the fullest, with energetic production numbers that make you tired merely watching them. Fame, High School Musical, and the zillion others of this genre owe their existence to this one.

The Women:
MGM. George Cukor. Screenplay: Anita Loos. (F. Scott Fitzgerald also contributed dialogue.) Norma Shearer, Rosalind Russell, Joan Crawford, Paulette Goddard, Joan Fontaine.
Claire Booth Luce’s play, adapted by Anita Loos (Gentlemen Prefer Blondes) with an all-star all women cast, is the most overt "woman’s picture" in an era that credibly boasts as the golden age of female actors and stories about women who would later be called liberated.

The writers and stars of the 1930's were molded by the social sensibilities of the 1920's when small town girls became "flappers" and "vamps", drank whiskey from flasks and in speakeasies, danced in short skirts, bobbed their hair, smoked cigarettes, and went to the big city to become independent. Movies of the 20's and 30's reflected and influenced this pop culture revolution. It wasn’t until the 1950's that women lost their bearings and reverted to the puritanical norm of pliant homemakers that required another revolution to free them from.